Here are 10 substitutes for lady fingers (with pictures!), also known as sponge fingers, they are the famous biscuits used when making tiramisu, layered trifle, or no-bake Italian cake. But what happens when you’re halfway through whipping up mascarpone and realize you're all out? Don’t panic—we've got 10 sweet ladyfinger alternatives that’ll save your dessert!
Jump to:
WHAT ARE LADY FINGER BISCUITS?
Lady finger biscuits—also known as sponge fingers—are light, airy, finger-shaped cookies made from whipped eggs, sugar, and flour. They’re slightly crisp on the outside and soft inside, perfect for soaking up coffee or liqueur in desserts like tiramisu. Think of them as the sweet, spongy building blocks of many classic European sweets!
10 LADY FINGER SUBSTITUTES
1. VANILLA WAFFERS
Vanilla wafers are crunchy, lightly sweet, and soak up espresso like a pro. They work especially well in tiramisu or layered pudding desserts. Plus, they're easy to find and kid-friendly.
✅ Great for: Tiramisu, trifles
🧁 Bonus: They keep their shape better than ladyfingers when soaked.
2. POUND CAKE
Got leftover pound cake? Slice it thin. It’s rich, buttery, and brings serious yumminess to your desserts. Use sparingly in place of lady fingers for a cake-ier, softer version of tiramisu.
✅ Great for: Boozy desserts, trifle
🍰 Tip: Toast slices slightly for structure.
3. MADELEINS
These delicate French biscuits are buttery, soft, and slightly spongy, making them a luxe swap for lady fingers. Their shell-like shape even looks fancy layered in desserts.
✅ Great for: Upscale tiramisu, individual parfaits
🇫🇷 Vibe: Très chic.
4. GENOISE SPONGE CAKE
If you’re feeling ambitious, make a thin layer of Genoise sponge cake and slice it into finger-sized strips. It’s airy, light, and actually closer to the texture of real sponge fingers.
✅ Great for: Classic tiramisu, entremets
🎂 Pro tip: Brush with espresso + rum.
5. BISCOFF BISCUITS
Spicy, sweet, and totally delicious—Biscoff biscuits (or cookies) bring a cinnamon kick to your dessert recipe. Want a next-level twist? Add a thin layer of Biscoff spread between layers for extra indulgence.
✅ Great for: Tiramisu with a twist, cheesecakes
🔥 Mood: Cozy and bold.
6. AMARETTI COOKIES
These almond-based Italian biscuits are crisp, chewy, and pack a punch of flavor. Crushed or whole, they bring a nutty, slightly bitter balance to sweet desserts—especially tiramisu with a twist.
✅ Great for: Espresso-soaked layers, deconstructed tiramisu
🌰 Tip: Use the soft version if you want a more sponge-like texture.
7. PAN DI SPAGNA (ITALIAN SPONGE CAKE)
An alternative name for sponge cake used in Italy. Slice it thin, and boom—you’ve got yourself a tiramisu base with hometown credibility.
✅ Great for: Authentic tiramisu, semifreddo
🇮🇹 Italian-approved
8. GRAHAM CRACKERS
While they have a different texture, graham crackers soften beautifully in layered desserts and pair well with mascarpone or whipped creams. Add a bit of cinnamon or espresso to enhance the flavor.
✅ Great for: Icebox cakes, no-bake desserts like cream mascarpone (an Italian mousse)
9. SHORT BREAD COOKIES
Rich, buttery, and delightfully crumbly—shortbread cookies are a fab substitute. They don’t soak as much liquid as sponge fingers, but their melt-in-your-mouth texture pairs beautifully with mascarpone and sweets like tiramisu.
✅ Great for: No-bake tiramisu, layered fridge desserts
🧈 Pro tip: Go easy on the espresso so they don’t fall apart!
10. PANETTONE
The ultimate festive cake! This Italian holiday bread is soft, sweet, and studded with raisins or candied fruit. Slice it into strips and layer it like sponge fingers—it soaks up mascarpone and coffee like a dream.
✅ Great for: Christmas tiramisu, winter trifles
🎄 Bonus: Adds a fruity, celebratory twist.
❓FAQS
Lady fingers get their name from their long, slender shape, which resembles delicate fingers—hence "lady" fingers!
Usually, no. Traditional lady fingers are made with wheat flour and are not gluten-free, unless specifically labeled as such.
No. Classic recipes typically include eggs and sometimes dairy, making them not vegan—unless it's a vegan version.
Some are! While many traditional lady fingers don’t contain milk or butter, it's best to check the label to confirm they are dairy free, especially if made commercially.
Did you make this recipe? Let me know what you think by leaving a ★★★★★ star rating & comment below. It genuinely helps me & I really appreciate your support! Nikki 💚
Comments
No Comments